“The Truest Paradise Is Love” A Review of Orpheus and Eurydice

By Timothy Ruppert

After reviewing Anaïs Mitchell’s Hadestown a few weeks ago, I found the opportunity to write on Pittsburgh Opera’s current production of Christoph Williblad Gluck’s 1762 opera Orpheus and Eurydice thoroughly irresistible, given that the assignment allowed me to investigate a question that Albert Camus pondered more than eighty years ago in his notebooks: Why does the story of Eurydice and her lyre-playing paramour recur so vibrantly in the literature of today? Perhaps Camus answered the question years before he asked it: “Absurdity is king, but love saves us from it.” Possibly the matter cannot be resolved at all beyond acknowledging love as a transformational force, utterly real, forever puzzling, and cosmically powerful. For an outstandingly thoughtful and moving drama of love in all its mysteriousness, plan to see Orpheus and Eurydice. Simply put, and without deliberate overstatement, this production qualifies as one of the most beautifully realized that I have seen from the ever-excellent Pittsburgh Opera, and no intelligent theatregoer in the city should miss it.

The story begins mournfully as the funeral of Eurydice (Lauren Snouffer, soprano) takes place beneath a colossal, leafless tree, its naked boughs crooked down toward the stage as if reaching out from the afterworld to collect her. Despondent yet defiant, Orphée (Stephanie Doche, mezzo-soprano) vows to recover his beloved: “Heartless tyrants,” the poet sings to the gods, “I will steal her back!” Enter Amour (Léa Nayak, soprano), a glittery deity on a golden bicycle, who sanctions Orphée’s mission to Hades, but with a mandate from Jupiter: should Orphée succeed in charming the Furies and rescuing Eurydice, he may not look upon her on the path back to life. And while the couple’s tragic journey home belongs to centuries of mythic history in which Eurydice dies a second time, look for Gluck’s version of the ancient story not simply to subvert expectations but to startle and, ultimately, to astonish.

From first to last, the principals’ vocal performances mesmerize, their exceptionality rendered more impressive by what Gluck’s music and Pierre-Louis Moline’s libretto together ask of these wonderful singers. Throughout its duration, Orpheus and Eurydice hovers between lamentation and laughter, between adagio and allegro. In the hands of a lesser cast, this close blending of sorrow and levity may well get mired in bathos. The singing here proves as narratively invaluable as it is profoundly gorgeous.

Consider too the inestimable contributions of the artistic team, led by José Maria Condemi (stage director) and Antony Walker (conductor), to the success of this distinctive production. Mary Ellen Stebbins’s inspired lighting perfectly sets each shifting mood as the story of Orphée’s sojourn in hell unfolds. Watch with particular care when red and purple lights repopulate the blanched, splintering tree with foliage in the evening’s closing moments. Steven Kemp gives us a scenic design brilliant in its sparsity, and Attack Theatre triumphs in the choreography. Costumer Robert Perdziola works inventively, most notably in creating for Doche a look reminiscent of Heathcliff in the latter half of Emily Brontë’s Wuthering Heights. In so limited a space, I cannot name each musician, chorus member, or dancer, although I wish that I could. They are to a person great storytellers.

Although Gluck’s Orpheus and Eurydice serves as a touchstone in Camus’s fiction for illusory hopes amid a voiceless cosmos, Pittsburgh Opera’s production of the piece evokes another observation from the Nobel laureate: “Love is injustice, but justice is not enough.” For a breathtaking exploration of a love that surpasses all bounds, terrestrial and otherwise, then hurry to Orpheus and Eurydice, most assuredly one of my very favorite shows of the year.

—TR

Pittsburgh Opera’s “Orpheus and Eurydice” plays at the Byham Theater, 101 6th Street, Pittsburgh, PA 15222, on November 20 and 22. For information and tickets, please click here.

 

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

css.php