By: Joseph Szalinski
June is a busy month for the Steel City. Pittsburgh Pride takes to the streets, baseball games are in full swing, and the Three Rivers Arts Festival features plenty of artisans, vendors, and rain. This translates into no viable parking, particularly at my beloved Smithfield-Liberty Garage. It’s during all this beautiful chaos that Vigilance Theatre Group opens its latest immersive production, Closing Time at the Moonside Cafe, written by Sean Collier and Renee Rabenold, and directed by Connor McCanlus (with assistance from Brooke Echnat), now running at Three Stories in Downtown Pittsburgh.
As with any immersive piece of theatre, there’s a frame to the production, and then numerous opportunities for audiences to become involved. Think of it like the Hot Pot equivalent of live entertainment. This time around, those intrigued enough to buy a ticket are treated to an evening of music. Things quickly get a little weird, prompting patrons to scatter throughout the sculpture-littered space as they attempt to ascertain exactly what is going on. People are encouraged to talk to other humans and visit the bar, where they can exchange light labor and divulge secrets in exchange for exclusive non-alcoholic beverages. They’re tasty and a fun detail of the show. Not feeling especially sociable? No worries. Sit back and watch the drama unfold before your eyes.

Actors brilliantly demonstrate their abilities to sing, improvise, and simultaneously stick to a script. Bradleigh Bell leads the charge as Knox, the cafe’s mysterious owner. Lyco, the host of the evening, is delightfully played by Noah Kendall. Working magic on the microphone are Marisa Postava as Merida, the story’s starlet, and Jess Uhler as Luna, her curious complement. Isaac Miller and Megha Pai provide plenty of laughs as Gus and Justina, one a bumbling busboy and the other a sheepish newer hire. Cap, the intimidating bouncer-type dude, is powerfully portrayed by Max Petrunya. Gwen Arbuckle and Harper York hold down the fort as bartenders, Vera and Mercury, respectively, the most sought-after cast members. Rounding out the talented cast/employees of the cafe are Laina Stanek as Kyrie, Hannah Brizzi as Vesper, Allie Burns as Livy, and John Feightner as Frank.
Technical Elements are equally marvelous as the performances. Music director/keyboardist Travis Rigby and drummer Brayden Ball provide a superb soundtrack to the staged strangeness, aided by Janus Young’s top-notch sound design. Remy Porter’s lighting design impeccably illuminates the insanity, highlighting the creative costuming courtesy of Allie Lampman-Sims. The discerning taste of set designer Heather Heitzenrater furnishes this wacky world. And, of course, none of this would be possible without the tireless efforts of stage managers Sun Marshall and Sarah Dugan.
The Three Stories venue is a cool space and a cooler concept. Owned and operated by the Pittsburgh Cultural Trust, it hosts free rentals for artists and companies in a black box theater, along with a downstairs space with dressing rooms and the like. Don’t worry, fellow Yinzers, there’s also a bar area.
Vigilance Theater Group is a unique organization that has been staging immersive shows since 2018. Comprised of folks who have incredibly interesting backgrounds from the cast to those behind the scenes, their productions are guaranteed to be supremely spellbinding. Even when faced with a sweaty sprint from West General Robinson Street Garage on the North Shore to Liberty Avenue in under 10 minutes, as someone who detests running, outside the scope of playing with my dog, I accepted the challenge because I knew they have something special in store.
-JS
Closing Time at the Moonside Cafe continues its run June 14, 18-21 & 25-27th at Three Stories in Downtown Pittsburgh















