By Michael Buzzelli
When an Old Man (Sam Lothard) and a Boy (Dionysius Akeem) roll into East Piney Grove, a small Black church in rural South Carolina, life is about to change for the entire congregation in Javon Johnson’s “Sanctified.”
Harold Jones (Emir J. Hardy) is running the parish church amid a lot of controversy. He wants to grow the church, expand and modernize. Whereas the Deacon (Charles Timbers) wants to keep things traditional, creating a rift between the preacher and his choir.
All the dissenting voices have their own agenda.
Piano player Thelma (Brenda Marks) can’t read sheet music and is unwilling to learn. The occasional nips from the flask she carries around increase and the church goers realize she’s got a drinking problem.
Jamal (Manny Walker) wants to be a gospel singer and a rapper. His sister, Monique (Marissa Lily) has a crush on the mysterious new Boy, who wants to be called Mister.
The pastor’s cousin, Dr. Pauletta Jones (Karla C. Payne) wants to overpower the choir with her operatic voice.
“Sanctified” is a musical and there’s a lot of plot and a lot of singing, it’s a glorious joyful noise.

The “Sanctified” cast is gigantic, but Johnson lifts every voice, and each actor gets the spotlight.
Willa Catherine “Katy” Cotten dazzles as Sarah. Her rendition of the title song, “Sanctified” is amazing.
Cheryl El Walker gets some of the best lines and delivers them flawlessly. Her singing voice is powerful.
Marks is hilarious as the tipsy pianist.
Lothard, literally and figuratively, brings soul to his character. Old Man/Sir is grounded and gently pressing forward with his own agenda. He and Akeem’s Boy/Mister have a dynamic chemistry.
Mils James plays the stuttering Bobby, who doesn’t stutter when he sings. James also supplied the kinetic choreography. He has all the moves. In the second act, he has a triumphant moment and plays it to the hilt.
While there are some lovely moments in “Sanctified,” it has a few too many moments. The show runs 2 hours and 25 minutes with a 15-minute intermission. There are, however, a plethora of lovely songs. The music composed by Rollo Dilworth and orchestrated by music director Dwayne Fulton is beautifully rendered.
The show won’t just resonate with gospel music fans, but it helps if you are one. The best thing about “Sanctified” is that there are no clear villains, only people struggling with different points of view. It’s glorious to see them come together and work for the greater good. Amen!
-MB
“Sanctified” runs until March 30th at the Madison Arts Center, 3400 Milwaukee Street, Pittsburgh, PA 15219. For more information and tickets, click here.