By Michael Buzzelli
Kitty Bennet (Annalisa D’Aguilar) and Georgiana Darcy (Olivia Leigh Ruhnke) come out from under the petticoats of their siblings in Lauren Gunderson and Margo Melcon’s “Georgiana & Kitty: Christmas at Pemberley.”
“Georgiana & Kitty: Christmas at Pemberley” completes the Gunderson-Melcon trilogy of Pride & Prejudice plays featuring the Bennet’s and the Darcy’s. Stories that take place after the final chapter of the iconic Jane Austen book.
The third part in the series, begins at Pemberley. The action happens concurrently with the last play in the series, “The Wickhams: Christmas at Pemberley.” But now, the Darcy and Bennet families continue to celebrate Christmas in the parlor, far away from the kitchen staff who were prevalent in the last chapter. Because the action is happening at the same time as the last play, Jane Bingley (Alex Manalo) is STILL pregnant.
The play could have used a “Previously at Pemberley” to catch the audience up on the events, but you need not have seen the last play to grasp the content of this one. If you haven’t seen the last one, it’s like watching “Rashomon,” but only from one angle. Seeing all of them just gives the audience member added nuance or flavor.
Georgiana Darcy and her friendship with the youngest member of the Bennet clan is the focal point of this chapter. Georgiana is an aspiring musician with a secret (maybe even more than one). In the first act, the audience learns that she has been secretly corresponding with a boy, Henry Grey (Nick Grosso), and keeping that correspondence from her snooty brother, Fitzwilliam Darcy (Juan Rivera Lebron).
The secret can’t remain secret much longer, because Henry and his friend Thomas O’Brien (Isaac Miller) are stopping by Pemberley on Boxing Day (December 26th). Henry has a secret of his own.
When known literary troublemaker Lydia Wickham (Alex Sheffield) finds a fateful letter, she causes more chaos for the Darcy and Bennet’s (Girl! Seriously).
Fitzwilliam Darcy is upset by the revelation. He can’t overcome his own pride or prejudice to give Henry a chance (Yes, Darcy name checks the book that made him a household name to romance readers everywhere).

“Georgiana & Kitty: Christmas at Pemberley” is a delightful addition to the Christmas at Pemberley series. Gunderson and Melcon know the characters almost as well as Jane Austen did.
Fan Fiction is a maligned genre, but Gunderson and Melcon are on the top of their game, painting a lovely triptych homage to Austen’s most produced work.
The cast is superb. Many of them returning from the last chapter in the trilogy (Lebron, Sheffield and Manalo are among the excellent returning cast members).
Sheffield’s Lydia is a delight. She’s the Steve Urkel of the Regency Romance. Kogut gets some of the wittiest, driest, drollest lines.
Georgiana and the Bennet’s are an imposing collection of strong women, but each one gets a moment to shine without overpowering the others.
D’Aguilar will win you over. This is more Georgiana’s story, and Ruhnke does a superb job as the protagonist. Ruhnke starts out as quiet and unassuming and an audience may wonder, “Why is the story about her?” She quickly goes from shy and reserved to a force to be reckoned with! It’s a fascinating transformation, expertly performed.
If a person was forced to pick a favorite Bennet sister, after Lizzy (Evelyn Hernandez), of course, my answer would have been, Mary (Gabrielle Kogut). After seeing “Georgiana & Kitty,” I may have switched my allegiance to Kitty. D’Aguilar is so bubbly and charismatic in the role.
Somedays you’re a Miranda and somedays you’re a Charlotte.
There are some men in the play, too. Rivera, Grosso, and Miller do a great job as well. Even though its a romance, the core the story is about the friendship between sisters and one sister-in-law.
Rivera and Ruhnke have terrific chemistry as siblings. One terse word from either of them caused roars of laughter.
Director Bria Walker-Rhoze does a marvelous job controlling the chaos of the ups-and-downs of a romantic comedy, even as it shifts from the gasp to laugh (and every emotion in between).
Even the set, by legendary scenic designer Tony Ferrieri, has a few surprises.
If you’re looking for a new (to Pittsburgh) Christmas show, this one has it all. No Janeite (or Austenite if you prefer) should miss “Georgiana & Kitty: Christmas at Pemberley.”
-MB
“Georgiana & Kitty: Christmas at Pemberley” runs from November 14 to December 6th at the City Theatre, 1300 Bingham, Pittsburgh, PA 15203. For tickets and additional information, click here.

