By Lonnie the Theater Lady
Neil Diamond collaborated with Anthony McCarten to write “A Beautiful Noise.” The play tells the “true story” of Neil Diamond’s journey from the beginning as a poor boy in Brooklyn to his current status as the internationally famous singer-songwriter. Diamond wrote all the music and lyrics in this biographical jukebox musical.
The show opens with Diamond’s therapist (Lisa Renee’ Pitts) encouraging an aging, “Neil-Now” (Robert Westenberg) to reflect on his life and career in hopes to lead him through the emotional pain he’s experiencing due to his failing health preventing him from doing what he loves best–touring. Therapy sessions are interspersed throughout the story as Diamond’s life and career are seen in flashbacks.
The doctor uses lyrics from Diamond’s own songbook to spark his memories. Through these sessions, Diamond’s lifelong feelings of dissatisfaction, self- doubt, and low self-confidence become evident. His greatest disappointments and many successes are exposed.
American Idol winner Nick Fradiani delights in the reprisal of his Broadway role as “Neil-Then.” He bears a strong resemblance to Diamond both physically and vocally. In the show, Ellie Greenwood (Kate A. Mulligan) describes his voice as “gravel wrapped in velvet.” Fradiani nails that vocal quality. The emotional expression in his vocals is stunning. He captures Diamond’s off-stage angst, his on-stage swagger, and dazzling charisma. It is a memorable, remarkable performance. Every one of his musical numbers is noteworthy.
Broadway veteran Robert Westenberg delivers a poignant, heart-wrenching portrayal of “Neil-Now” and his struggle with his failing health. At the show’s climax, Westenberg and Fradiani sing a powerful duet, “I Am…I Said.” The stark contrast between the weaker “Neil-Now” and the vibrant “Neil-Then” is heartrending.
Jaye Posner (Tiffany Tatreau) is Diamond’s first wife. As their marriage is disintegrating, Tatreau vocalizes an emotional, impactful rendition of “Love on the Rocks.” So powerful. It caused a flush of teary eyes in the audience.
Hannah Jewel Kohn plays Diamond’s second wife. She lights up the stage with a star quality reminiscent of Ann Margaret. Her lovely vocals and commanding stage presence are evident in every scene. Kohn sparkles in the number “Forever in Blue Jeans” as she leads the bedazzled denim-clad troupe in a joyous, uplifting romp.
Spencer Donavan Jones provides another beautiful moment, in a night of beautiful moments, when he sings “Shilo,” a touching, sweet song about a lonely child’s imaginary friend. Lovely.
The story takes a backseat in this captivating production. The colorful neon lights, sparkling sequined costumes, and well-choreographed dance numbers harken back to old-time Las Vegas night club shows.
“A Beautiful Noise” is an inspiring, delightful way to spend an evening. The outstanding showmanship exhilarates, entertains, and leaves one wanting more!
-LtTL
“A Beautiful Noise” runs from September 9 until September 14 at Benedum Center, 237 Seventh Avenue, Pittsburgh, PA 15222. For more information, click here.
